Looking to add some seclusion to your backyard oasis? A privacy fence not only creates a personal retreat but also boosts your home’s value and security. But here’s the million-dollar question (or more accurately, the thousand-dollar question): should you buy pre-made panels or build your fence from scratch? As a leading privacy fence installer in Anne Arundel County, All Around Fence & Decks has seen homeowners wrestle with this decision countless times. Let’s break down the real costs of both approaches so you can make the best choice for your home and wallet.
The True Cost Comparison: Pre-Made vs. DIY
When comparing fence options, the numbers tell an interesting story. Pre-made fence panels typically cost around $230 per 8-foot section when you factor in all materials. These panels come ready to install, saving you considerable assembly time. On the flip side, building a traditional board-and-stringer fence from individual components might cost closer to $175 per equivalent section-potentially saving you about 25% on materials.
But here’s where things get interesting. Those savings can quickly disappear when you factor in other costs. Let’s look at what else goes into the equation:
Material Costs Beyond the Basics
The fence panels themselves are just the beginning. You’ll also need:
- Posts (typically $25-45 each)
- Concrete for setting posts ($5-10 per post)
- Post caps ($5-15 each)
- Hardware and fasteners ($50-100 total)
- Stain or sealant ($30-50 per gallon)
These extras add up quickly, regardless of which approach you take. However, when buying individual boards, you’ll need more fasteners and might have more waste material than with pre-fabricated panels.
The Time Investment
Time is money, as they say. Building from scratch requires measuring and cutting each board, which significantly increases labor time. A DIY fence project typically takes a weekend warrior 2-3 weekends to complete a modest 150-foot perimeter fence. Pre-made panels can cut that time roughly in half.
If you’re taking time off work or giving up other opportunities, that time has real value. Even at a modest $20 per hour of your time, that difference could represent $300-600 in “hidden costs.”
When Pre-Made Panels Make More Sense
Pre-fabricated panels shine in several scenarios:
You’re short on time: If getting the project done quickly matters, panels win hands down. They’re designed for relatively fast installation.
You have limited tools: Building from scratch requires more specialized tools like circular saws, drills, and levels. Renting these tools adds $100-200 to your project cost.
Your design needs are standard: If you’re happy with common panel styles and heights (typically 6-8 feet), pre-made options offer plenty of variety without custom work.
You’re working alone: Panels are easier for one person to handle than managing dozens of individual boards.
When Building From Scratch Wins
Despite the convenience of panels, building from scratch has its advantages:
You have an irregular layout: Sloped yards or unusual dimensions are much easier to accommodate with individual boards than with rigid panels.
You want something truly custom: Specific designs, board spacing, or decorative elements are all easier to incorporate when building board-by-board.
You’re working with a tight budget: If material cost is your primary concern and you have time to spare, the savings from building yourself can be significant.
You enjoy woodworking: Some homeowners simply enjoy the craftsmanship aspect of building something by hand.
The Hidden Costs to Consider
Before making your decision, factor in these often-overlooked considerations:
Tools needed: A basic fence build requires a post-hole digger, circular saw, drill, level, and measuring tools. If you don’t own these, add $200+ for purchases or $50-100 for rentals.
Waste factor: When buying individual boards, plan for 10-15% extra materials to account for waste, mistakes, and damaged pieces.
Delivery fees: Large lumber orders often incur delivery charges of $50-100, while you might be able to transport pre-made panels yourself with a pickup truck.
Permit costs: Most areas require permits for fences (typically $50-200), regardless of which approach you take.
The Professional Installation Option
Of course, there’s a third option: hiring professionals. Professional installation typically adds $10-20 per linear foot to your project cost. For a 150-foot perimeter fence, that’s $1,500-3,000 in labor.
However, professionals bring several advantages:
- They finish much faster (often in 1-2 days)
- They handle permits and know local codes
- Their work typically comes with warranties
- They have specialized tools and experience
- They can spot potential problems before they occur
Long-Term Value Considerations
The cheapest option upfront isn’t always the most economical in the long run. Consider these factors:
Durability: Professionally installed fences often last longer due to proper post-setting techniques and material selection.
Maintenance needs: Improper installation can lead to leaning, warping, or premature rot-all requiring costly repairs.
Resale value: A well-built fence adds more value to your home than one with obvious DIY shortcomings.
Making Your Decision
When deciding between pre-made panels, building from scratch, or hiring professionals, ask yourself:
- How valuable is my time?
- How comfortable am I with construction projects?
- Do I have the necessary tools?
- Is my yard layout straightforward or complex?
- How important is customization?
- What’s my true budget when ALL costs are considered?
For many homeowners, the sweet spot is using pre-made panels but installing them themselves. This approach balances convenience with cost savings while still giving you the satisfaction of a DIY project.
Whatever approach you choose, proper planning is essential. Measure carefully, understand your soil conditions, and check local regulations before purchasing materials. Companies like All Around Fence & Decks can provide guidance even if you ultimately decide to tackle the project yourself.
Remember, a privacy fence is a long-term investment in your property. Sometimes paying a bit more upfront-whether for quality materials or professional installation, dividends in longevity, appearance, and peace of mind. After all, the best fence is one you can install once and enjoy for many years to come.
Also Read
